The historical legacy of American Socialism

The recent book The Socialist Party of America: A Complete History by Jack Ross, a contributor to this blog, is a must-read for anyone interested in the meaning of American socialism. The books starts in the nineteen century with the early socialists of America, some more close to Marx and others more similar to Bakunin. What seems to be the center of the book is American social democracy, but when Ross speaks about social democracy, he doesn’t refer to the Keynesianism of liberals like Paul Krugman, but the populist Jeffersonian decentralism of Eugene Debs and Norman Thomas.

Both Debs and Thomas are central to history of American socialism. The book refers to Debs as biggest champion in American history of the cause of free speech. Being imprisoned for a political speech in the context of World War I, there are few politicians that could match his anti-imperialism and conviction, and Ross mentions a possible kindred spirit in the present, the conservative libertarian Ron Paul.

Debs was a five time presidential candidate, a man who came from a prosperous immigrant family from Terre Haute, Indiana but who gave his life to the cause of workers and peace. Ross mentions that if Debs had been the presidential candidate of the Populist Party, history could have been very different; if the socialists would have gotten the endorsement from the unions, they might have been able to become an organization similar to social democratic parties in Europe. Ross makes clear his admiration for Norman Thomas, a Presbyterian minister opposed to both the New Deal and World War II, who ran six times for president as a candidate of the Socialist Party of America. Like Debs, Thomas was an anti-imperialist whose commitment to peace made him an ally of the Old Right.

Both Debs and Thomas were patriots in the most profound sense of the word; like the early socialists, their cause was a new American revolution against the oppression of capitalism, but their desired model was very different from Marxian European Socialism.

Why socialism failed to take root in the United States is question that gnaws at the edges of the book. While there is not one answer, Jack Ross thinks that the early days of the Socialist Party were crucial to their tragic future, because despite the fact that Eugene Debs was a true hero for the working class, the Socialist Party could never build a strong alliance with national labor organizations. I think there is some truth to that but the question of race is very important; the ties of socialists with racists and even with the Ku Klux Klan in some regions generate a strong problem with minorities in the days of Debs despite that he and an important part of the leadership of the Socialist Party were anti-racist. Also the question of Zionism made some Jewish socialists change their anti-interventionist position.

The text attempts to refute the Popular Front narrative that has been common in the history of the American Left — the role of communism and especially the Communist Party USA were overstated in the historiography of the Cold War. Though the Popular Front realignment was due largely to communists, it is very hard to think that this explains why some radicals support the Democratic Party today. Socialism was misunderstood in the context of Cold War as a synonym for communism, despite that in the American tradition they were particularly opposed to one another.

The attempt to defend the historic American social democracy is complex, because today social democracy is synonym of left-liberalism and identity politics. Maybe Milwaukee could be an interesting example for the history of American socialism, a city with a history of mayors from the Socialist Party which were efficient and transparent in the way to govern — the last one was Frank Zeidler, elected in 1948. John Norquist who called himself a fiscally conservative socialist was elected in 1998 as a member of the Democratic Party. I think that while Norquist never hold the fame of Bernie Sanders, he would probably had been closer to a more populist vein of the socialism that the Socialist Party used to represent.

On the legacy of American socialism, Ross points three groups that emerge from the break-up of the Socialist Party of America: the Schatmanites of SDUSA, the reformers of DSOC and the radicals of SPUSA. While Schatmanites were fundamental to the development of neoconservativism and very hard to identify as socialists, you can hear prominent neocons like David Frum supporting universal health care and a hike of the minimum wage. However, if non-interventionism is what used to be the principal characteristic of the American socialism, that makes them, definitively, something else.

DSOC, now DSA, is very small and despite having prominent members like Cornel West it is still part of left-wing of the Democrat Party, and it’s not event as prominent as some other progressive groups. The SPUSA still participates in some elections, but shows weaker and weaker results; their last elected member Karen Kubby was a councilwoman from Iowa City, who switched parties to the Greens, a relatively a quite common choice for members of the SPUSA.

The possibilities of development of socialism in America despite the odds were very exciting. The book relates that in the beginnings of the last century there was even a proposal of members of the Socialist Party to form an independent socialist republic in Texas. But the most clear possibility for the development of American Socialism was if Martin Luther King would have survived and run as a third party candidate in 1968.

King’s politics were close to Eugene Debs and Norman Thomas, but obviously being a prominent Afro-American leader he could rally the support of minorities. Without King the third party effort of the People’s Party failed. In the 80s the Citizens Party was born out of the Barry Commoner presidential campaign but its form of liberal reformism never became powerful. In 1984 the Green Party was born. The Green Party, despite being identified with the Keynesianism of Ralph Nader, was born in the legacy of the New Left. In the 80s socialists and anarchists founded the Left Green Network, whose purpose was to drive the party to the left, among them was the social theorist and eco-anarchist Murray Bookchin. Under his influence the Left Green Network developed a decentralist platform fighting for change at the local level, but with time the Left Green Network’s priorities fell off in favor of the more liberal wing of the party that was more focused on the national level.

I think Ross’s book fails to mention the importance of one of the Green Party founders to the history of socialism in America, Howie Hawkins was a member of SPUSA that became an ally of Murray Bookchin, but also was key into drafting Ralph Nader as the Green Party candidate. While the 2000 Nader campaign caused a backlash against the Green Party for allegedly being a spoiler, party insiders had said that the organization wasn’t as strong as in the early days of the party. The Green Party failed to become a biggest threat to Democratic Party in the next election, the liberal wing decided to choose as presidential candidate an unknown lawyer David Cobb in 2004, against Nader who was supported by socialists and anarchists and even some libertarians and paleoconservatives.

Nader running as an independent didn’t help in the party building, but neither did running a weak candidate like Cobb. In 2008 Nader built a relatively similar alliance running as an independent, while greens choose Cynthia McKinney a popular black congresswoman, but with Barack Obama as the Democratic Party nominee both Nader and McKinney showed poor numbers. In 2012 they ran Jill Stein, a physician, and got numbers far from the ones of Nader in 2000. Stein, unlike Nader, never showed interest in making inroads with the paleoconservative or libertarian vote and was in search of progressive supporters. The Green Party has evolved from libertarian municipalism of the 80s to the liberal reformism of the 90s to eco-socialism today. Though eco-socialism is a term connected to Murray Bookchin, I think today eco-socialism has in more in common with state interventionism in the name of ecology. The Green Party has embraced identity politics, which could be a problem if as in the past there is need of the votes from what used to be the Old Right. Though decentralism is still on their platform, they focus a lot more on the presidential campaign.

Ross mentions that the Old Right and socialist left had a lot in common, and I agree. Their foreign policy was the biggest common cause, Bill Kauffman goes as far as to suggest Pat Buchanan is the second coming of Eugene Debs. The text fails to mention that Goldwater speechwriter Karl Hess was also a former member of the Socialist Party, but unlike the neocons he went leftward in the context of the Vietnam War. But the text mentions something often forgotten, the fact that after his presidential campaigns Norman Thomas started to sound closer to Peter Kropotkin, denouncing state bureaucracy and calling for the development of mutual aid. In those days he sounded closer to eco-anarchists like Murray Bookchin or Christian anarchists like Dorothy Day. But even with libertarians there is still some room for an alliance, in the 2014 election Howie Hawkins the eco-socialist candidate of the Green Party for Governor of New York opposed the Keystone XL Pipeline on the grounds that it violated property rights.

A curious fact is that Jack Ross was a writer of The American Conservative, and I think he could be defined as a heterodox left-conservative, but his book could make the radical left think again in their own tradition. Today the possibility of America having a president who calls himself a socialist is real. Few journalists predicted Sanders’ success, the liberal left is tired of the corporatism of the Clintons, and Sanders’ message is resonating with a public tired of the merger of Wall Street and Washington. But neither Debs nor Thomas would had been proud of Sanders, who is not only much more bureaucratic than them, he is also a supporter of the American Empire.

Ross points that socialists are like prophets, and he is right. The historic antiwar activist David McReynolds said on the 100 year anniversary of the Socialist Party that the victory of socialism in America was not going to be when someone who was part of the socialist left is in a place of power — a sly reference to the neocons. Likewise, a victory for Bernie Sanders could easily be less the vindication of American Socialism than its defeat.

I don’t know if America will see a character like Debs or Thomas again. Ralph Nader was closer to the Old Left in speaking about a broad left/right alliance against the corporate state and the importance of the concept of community activism. But Ron Paul was even closer because in making foreign policy his priority he was able unify libertarians, conservatives, progressives and socialists against the American Empire, and like Debs and Thomas he want a Republic. I think that the book shows that not only the New Left had a lot in common with the Old Right but actually the Old Left had also a lot in common with the Old Right, a call for a Jeffersonian decentralist Republic, and whether one calls that libertarian, conservative or socialist doesn’t make much difference. The socialist left in America had strong democratic convictions and was opposed to all totalitarian forms of socialism. Though today there is still a caricature of socialism as a synonym of Soviet communism, but the youth is not interested in buying it.

There is a long noble history of American socialism, men and woman who choose to believe that they can build a new country, based on the ideals on which the old one was founded. We may need to rediscover it, as the socialism we’re most familiar with is much more pernicious. America has in the last century started to live under a kind of socialism, the state socialism of Bismarck, proper to a military empire like the ones between World Wars. Later, in the context of Vietnam War, Murray Rothbard described a “nixonian socialism,” and since Reagan, neoconservativism can be understood as right-wing social democracy. If conservatives have been vital for the triumph of some forms of socialism, maybe they could be a factor in bringing about a future for the more positive kind. Maybe the descendents of the prairie socialists are supporting Donald Trump but I think they could be waiting for a new Eugene Debs.

(Image source)


  1. Free Sex Meet With Local Women:

    Popular tags: 35 year old guy dating, online dating meme, kpop dating variety shows, indian dating sites in new york, the hook up boca raton fl, the best dating sites in ireland, webdate com worlds best free personals dating chat, dating someone who drinks more than you, gay dating sites cape town, 100 free dating australia, malaysia chinese dating site, examples of introductions for dating sites, dating buzz contact details, dating websites overweight, harry styles denies dating taylor swift, senior dating 100 free, free hookup websites like craigslist, what is a real free dating site, my ex is dating someone else already, dating irish woman, how to tell if she’s dating others, dating site relationships, online dating how long to wait to meet, free dating in pittsburgh, online dating without paying, dating silver by hallmarks, dating site profile search by email, dating a married leo man, mental illness dating site, divorced parents dating rules, kyrgyzstan dating customs, what is the best time for a dating scan, yvonne and zach dating 2012, online free dating site for singles, speed dating esl reading, online dating pick ups, sparks speed dating west palm beach, fat man single ladies, spiritual dating free, over 55 speed dating, best online dating site south africa, interracial dating sites in georgia, dating website openers, dating site checklist, dating someone from another culture, sophomore girl dating senior guy, best hookup uk, theme dating sites, irish online dating, iac dating companies, polish dating london, living at home after college dating, what kind of man are you dating, dating sites greece, naruto dating games on deviantart, minecraft server roleplay dating, best looking dating websites, single hookup go, totally free american dating sites, dating service washington dc, dating website clone, dating boy scout uniforms, matchmaking queue status locked, online dating addiction, hindi matchmaking online free, central park hook up, mainland dating owner jane metcalfe, dating philadelphia pa, senior internet dating sites, irish dating websites, val dancing with the stars dating 2015, nascar dating assassin, thousand oaks hook up, hook up whatsapp, saudi arabia dating site, dating events in san francisco, dark souls 2 matchmaking requirements, dating laws in florida 2014, how gender roles have changed in regard to dating in the last 50 years, filmul blind dating online, what are all the free dating sites, younger guy dating single mom, dating ocd, true stories of online dating, dating app usa, sabah dating site, dating new bern nc, dating sites with pictures, mens dating coach, tyndall dating site uk, dating invoices, my 20 year old daughter is dating a 30 year old, if a guy jokes about dating you, watch marriage not dating indo sub, wny dating sites, dating a recently separated guy, christian dating sites in netherlands, am fm antenna hookup, dating vs marriage meme, dating ideas in london, bravo matchmaking show, hindu matchmaking chart, weed hook up melbourne, free anime dating games for iphone, dating for 2 months and she stopped calling, matchmaking oulu, dating 20 year age difference, devon aoki dating, hook up girl meaning, doha dating sites, hook up iphone 5 to car, best dating app in san francisco, quotes about your best friend dating your brother, psych cast dating, parksville dating site, tween dating sites for middle schoolers, dating site hippies, best dating sites boston, free dating sites in glasgow scotland, totally free christian senior dating sites, hottest dating site in usa, how to know if your girl is dating another guy, seventh day adventist dating rules, dating keys, matchmaking hollywood, how to break up with someone you’re dating, dating microsoft, east liverpool dating, create your own online dating website, tips for dating a hispanic woman, tagged dating site reviews, online dating site for free in usa, free messaging dating sites in asia, what are the best dating apps free, online dating in dc, be2 international dating site, polish dating agency, dating hull, dating services scottsdale, ihk speed dating hamm, 100 free dating site without credit card, best dating site for divorcees, dating calculator pregnancy, debra messing dating co star, dating grafton, carbon dating of fossils, online dating crushed my confidence, speed dating edmonton 2016, free register online dating, hilarious online dating stories, when to give up on dating, is george st. pierre dating anyone, casual dating app test, 27 year old man dating 20 year old woman, rawalpindi dating site, dating a doctor website, dating besked, dating sites in lko, jojo wwe dating justin gabriel, wealthy dating uk, ourtime dating service phone number, dating ayrshire scotland, fifty dating scotland, derek ramsay dating, mystery online dating tips, how accurate is ultrasound dating pregnancy, crew dating, beer dating guide, free dating christchurch new-zealand, old school dating websites, dating website for iitians, dating radioisotopes, legitimate free hookup sites, which free dating site is best, vh1 reality dating shows, essay about dating online, gay sugar daddy dating sites uk free, dating royal doulton plates, free dating sites with photos, indian dating chat, dating bari, best dating site for anime fans, homestuck dating site, android location based hookup, speed dating berlin samstag, brazilian jiu jitsu dating, speed dating chicago 20s, times dating agency, is he more than a hookup, online dating saigon, 5 signs you’re dating a loser, dating places for couples in delhi, what to do when online dating fails, lgr speed dating, speed dating en el df, alternative dating sites to okcupid, tiger tiger newcastle speed dating, why internet dating is good, leuke dating teksten, qz race dating, kathmandu dating service, best dating sites in netherlands, how to sign up for online dating sims 3, pof dating site in english, friends dating ex boyfriends, the hookup culture only exists, why do guys ignore you after a hookup, cleveland matchmaking services, seniors dating app, singles dating in los angeles, amino acid dating range, speed dating calgary over 50, tamil dating app, trusted dating website, fish for dating website, the hook up fishing guide service, free phone hook up lines, ultimate dating profile, dating geneva switzerland, motorcycle dating australia, knoxville asian dating, free dating site in algeria, 101 online christian dating, thought catalog dating in new york, love singles dating site, 50 year old dating 19 year old, dating sites in vizag, dating site username ideas male, speed dating vlaanderen, american dating rules bases, fat dating uk, reputable dating sites nz, christian woman dating a muslim man, boyfriend online dating profile, dating tips for teenage girl, design dating website, dating sites for students uk, dating makkum pottery, lavalife dating line, old white hart northampton speed dating, gay dating sites greece, dating in the electronic age, dating portal fГјr akademiker, dating lamp sockets, why does dating have to be so hard, free dating brisbane, sample about me for a dating site, charlotte and gaz dating 2014, what to write about yourself in a dating profile, dating program kanal 5, dating in new hampshire, 22 year old dating 17 year old illegal, guardian dating website uk


  2. Sexy women in your city are looking for dating:

    Popular tags: dating dna free, free dating sites reviews 2013, how to make a dating relationship work, search email for dating sites, may club vr dating sx, dating logo psd, freddie stroma dating 2013, speed dating events in mumbai, dutch dating app, what is casual dating yahoo, top dating sites chicago, online dating sites reviews 2015, non single dating, 24 year old man dating 31 year old woman, dating sites in tanzania, dating varanasi, dating kerala kannur, online dating by breast size, wroclaw dating site, we are dating eng sub ep 5, plunder pirates matchmaking, how to end dating relationship, birthday present for a guy you just started dating, dating korean american guys, ing dating, best gay hookup apps australia, top ten dating websites uk, mature matchmaking, speed dating gay lille, top hookup sites ireland, dating filipina in kuwait, full hookup camping, guardian dating prices, dating bakersfield, dating a girl waiting for marriage, online dating example first message, dating sites for kuwait, life begins at dating site, roommate speed dating, 20 year old dating 16 year old legal, free dating classified ads, dating site tips first message, diapermates dating, best dating app south america, dating in cork city, kitchen sink drain hookup, why does online dating not work, dating syrian girl, dating someone with avoidant attachment, things to write on dating sites, flirting and dating websites, advice for dating a navy seal, china dating online, macros online dating, mr mrs fresh dating, craigslist eugene dating, dating someone for 6 weeks, restaurant dating in the dark amsterdam, egypt matchmaking, speed dating hamburg Гјber 50, stratocaster pickup dating, preston speed dating, dating site france free, foto dating seite, bengali girl dating in kolkata, lunch dating nyc, chemistry dating site scams, propane hook up kit, best dating website perth, jamie oliver dating site, tips for dating an irish man, speed dating bournemouth poole, tunesie dating, quotes about best friend dating your ex, dream of dating my crush, female led relationship dating service, what do you say in a message online dating, how do you hook up an ethernet switch, speed dating events in boston ma, online dating for polyamory, dating site app on blackberry, internet dating safety act new york, online dating chat rooms chennai, best dating website in bangalore, leicester indian speed dating, dating springbok puzzles, interview for dating my daughter, smoke weed dating, confusing dating, what is dating tinder, mila kunis dating site, what type of girl are you dating, ask ganesha kundali matchmaking, cumbria online dating, so sick of online dating, local dating no sign up, cliche dating profile, jazz dating website, food product dating california, am i dating a human or an onion, dating jews, take me out dating site, dating party girl, best dating site saudi arabia, bbc french speed dating, aquarius speed dating, dating skills definition, catholic view on online dating, best online dating site new york city, hook up hiphop 2013, free dating sites like skout, witty quotes for dating profile, mkx matchmaking unfair, what to write in a dating email, best dating sites for over 40, dating site india free, cts speakers dating, 100 free dating sites in turkey, dating in milan italy, hookup tampa, we’re not dating but she still mine, i’m dating a recently divorced man, dating private label, youngstown dating, how accurate dating scan 6 weeks, internet dating sites for professionals, 2 types of dating, who is austin mahone dating now, fantasy dating, free south african lesbian dating sites, 18 year olds dating minors laws, dating stuart florida, dating letter examples, dating my crush’s friend, free dating site vietnam, is online dating worth the money, i’m dating the ice princess 2 soft copy download, man dating profile example, pinay dating site, t shirt dating my daughter, dating sites that accept gift cards, rn52 hookup, good profiles for online dating, dating websites singapore, what is dating a girl, dating woman 15 years older, social network free dating, funny old fashioned dating advice, hookup atlanta, dating while depressed, lesbian dating houston tx, speed dating in syracuse ny, did kristen really hook up with jax, list of new zealand dating sites, christian dating for free delete account, 8 simple rules for dating my teenage daughter online, stepsapart dating, totally free muslim dating sites, dating in swindon, dating light bulbs, chelsea dating, suicide dating site, miami beach dating scene, online dating sarnia ontario, free mobile dating apps australia, dating sites albania, how to make money from dating sites, limerick dating site, ncsu dating site, online dating sites in lucknow, dating woman eating disorder, match dating website phone number, how long before dating after separation, adventist singles dating sites, dating for over 40’s south africa, best dating site in russia, online dating site toronto, family dating site, free dating no sign up sites, dating websites in india for free, austria dating website, what is the most popular free dating site, free online dating in hyderabad, mv222 dating, speed dating lille avis, fort myers florida dating, dating begins forty co uk, grown woman single, dating old photographs clothing, dating someone with the same name as your mom, dating site business model, dating site for dancers uk, 100 free dating chat, great expectations online dating reviews, at first sight dating app reviews, zodiac dating website, three sisters dating site, dating antique oak furniture, dating nearby app, hook up geneva, dating matters broward county, job dating limoges 2015, promotion codes for dating sites, mn dating services, i am dating a girl with herpes, dream analysis dating celebrity, browning a5 shotgun dating, dating coach raleigh nc, kelowna matchmaking services, he’s dating the transgender, dating waltham abbey, columbia missouri hook up, casual dating plattform, dating horoscope app, good starting messages for online dating, dating a police officer advice, dating a capricorn man tips, dating ring podcast, matchmaking 128, app for dating india, free online dating for 20 somethings, good usernames for dating site, sm confirms dating, rsvp dating site australia, willis family dating rules, dating italian woman, dating in ahmednagar maharashtra, regles speed dating, dating at 45 years old, dating a sagittarius female, dating les paul studio, alex turner dating history, nick holder no more dating djs lyrics, best dating coaches in the world, speed dating south wales, date hookup customer service number, hook up propane tank to house, bender gay dating website, youtube farmers only dating site, cosmopolitan sa dating site, dating for bigger guys, monogamous dating, free dating portsmouth, sign up free dating sites, sportsman dating site, free dating sites for canada, weird niche dating sites, popular dating apps in thailand, sofa dating, funny lines for dating profiles, latin dating singles, sugar mummy dating sites in zimbabwe, gay catholic dating sites


Leave a Reply to Jamesprion Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s